Thursday, February 18, 2010

Why the mineral-rich states are the most fucked up states in the country…??

The mineral Rich states are all covered with forests, are the greatest hub for the tribal population who are far away from the world that runs in the cities and towns. Lack of schools, make them uneducated hence unskilled in comparison to the city population (School Chale Hum is a complete failure in such areas). But they are not completely unskilled for their skill lies in agriculture and other rural occupations.

Now, the government here has acquired a model of development which is always injected to our brains through our school text books and TV. The model has always advocated the setup of Industries, Plants and factories as the main infrastructure for development. And in the name of this developmental model that involves mindless mining, setting up of steel plants, aluminium plants etc. millions of tribal are getting displaced. The rehabilitation policy of the government has only reduced them from the possession of acres of lands to a one room house. (I have been to Hatia, the area where the displaced from the HEC (Heavy Engineering Corporation) land are rehabilitated). The displaced are promised employment, but in the race of skilled labours, where do the illiterates and the people whose expertise lies only in agriculture, stand? The answer is quite obvious… they form the much needed manual labours in the factories with a meagre salary. Another aspect is, it has triggered migration in large no. to the other states in search of livelihood especially to the cities Delhi, Bombay and Kolkata. These migrants work as domestic labours in the posh areas of such cities.

Now why the government finds no difficulty in neglecting the lives of these sufferers? Right now I can only think of two reasons…
1) to fulfil the Hunger for more and more Electricity among the people of towns and cities esp. the Metros.
2) Displacement of people increases the availability of cheap manual labours in the country.

This problem has also triggered a rise of an armed rebellion group called the Maoists (Naxalites). The people who have lost their faith in the current form of government have joined hands together to overthrow Democracy because they feel that doesn’t matter whichever party comes to power, the UPA or the NDA the loot for minerals will continue since for them the growth rate of GDP is more important than the lives of the poor. It’s always the arms race or the Kashmir issue that has been more important than the basic rights of our own people. The emergence of such revolts is quite obvious if a certain section of a society is denied its basic survival rights. I guess this is why we struggled against the British Regime. (Not to forget that Bhagat Singh was a freedom fighter for us but a terrorist for the British ; there are always two perspectives)

But then there are people who still believe in this Democracy and are struggling through Gandhian ways of protesting like for example, Medha Patekar of Narmada bachao Andolan, and Dayamani Barla in Jharkhand against Arcelor-Mittal, that seeks 12,000 acres of land to build the world’s largest steel plant, by displacing about 40,000 tribal. Interestingly, Jharkhand has a history of people’s movements that have enabled the tribal to fight for their land, forests and survival rights e.g. the Koel-Karo movement, Netarhat Movement etc. After being cheated in the name of TATA and HEC the tribal here rose in the Gandhian way to protest and as a result of this, even after signing of more than a hundred MOUs with the multinational, international and the national companies none of them have been able to flourish.

Now the Indian government has launched operation Green Hunt which is currently operative in Chhattisgarh in a secretive manner. It’s almost a month and very little news have been emitted from the area. Last news we got was on 10thFebruary 2010 when Supreme Court ordered the Government to produce the 12 villagers picked by the paramilitary forces in front of the court. And the RTI made by Mr. Pathak, Leader of PUCL, as to know how many innocent villagers have been killed so far, responding to which the government accepted that four innocents have been killed. But, looking into the past actions the government, prior to the HUNT had released 1 lac such people who were arrested under false allegations of being a Naxalite, in Chhattisgarh. Then in the Manipur Issue, where Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act 1958 is imposed, that gives the Indian Army every right to Kill anyone under suspicion of being a member of the separatist Militancy, where more of civilians are killed than the Army or the Militant revolutionaries.

Now with this kind of History in the nearest past, can the Forces of India be trusted with the Green Hunt?
Is Armed revolt the only way out from this crisis situation?
Are there any other hidden agendas of the government because the Green Hunt will hardly scare the Naxals since they are themselves armed?
In this whole loot of minerals and the game of Violence and Counter-violence between the Government and the Naxals, who is the ultimate sufferer? and Does anyone even care?
Is it the Democracy that has failed us or we have failed the democracy?
If you go with the 2nd one, Will the future politicians and the makers of the country be innovative enough to device a middle path so that the voices of all sections of the society don't remain unheard?

I have tried to keep the blog post as open ended as possible so that we can discuss more on the issue and use this space as a forum…

Thank you.

9 comments:

  1. I would like to experiment with the second option which you have suggested in your post. If our forefathers like Jaipal Sing Munda and others could get certain rights for us after debating in the Constituent Assembly then surely the modern generation can do better. We just need to believe in ourselves. And yes we are not losers, just that we are playing the favourite game of our opponents

    ReplyDelete
  2. i m weak at history my pals but the present scenario of our jharkhand`s development is at stake and no doubts dese r all due to ruined politics of curropt personals . U know my father is himself govt officer n he has to face lots of problem their life is hell out here due to naxals n all other stuffs . every now n then inidents of kiddnapping extortions etc r at peak dese daz in jharkhand . i was working in jharkhand chatra morcha for 8 months in 2007-2008 as joint secretary i can understand how we youth want to change our society but these old senior ones are not letting us to do ..
    i tried my level best and still alwaz i take my keen interst in dese kinds of debates .....
    u have the best platform of proving this
    do good achieve gr8 yrs of success ... any kinda help in future ... i m a call away.....

    besta luk

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the 1st root cause for all this is HUNGER...
    According to me Hunger is of 2 types....
    1.for food that we eat
    2.for money..its like lust..

    and the 2nd root cause is "Lack of education"
    I dont support our Goverment or Maoists (Naxalites)..
    Both of them r motherfF------...
    They r just shelfish...and think of :
    1.themself &
    2.present
    due to which people like us suffers..
    None of them think about our Mother India...thats why i call them Mother F-----s...
    And if anybody tries to raise voice....he is killed...and the neighbours they keep their mouth shut...bcoz its not them who is in trouble...but they never think...that they could be in that situation one day...

    I recently saw a old serial called Channakya...man its amazing we should see that...
    Vishnu Gupt(main character)he should be called as Father of our Nation...not that Gandhi...(he is also an ass)...
    Vishnu Gupt was the 1st one in the indian history who thought of united india....hats off to Father of our Nation Vishnu Gupt...

    and we indians cant blame anybody for all this...its all IN OUR BLOOD...
    we can see from our history....

    The only solution is AROUSAL...we should not expect from others we should start it...
    i really appreciate your work...
    I think JESUS has to come and this time to india...who can only improve the situation... .
    And i am sure i wll be working for him..and i ask u .. if u get a chance
    never miss to serve for 1.GOD 2.HUMANKIND 3.Mother India..
    God Bless u all...
    love nachi

    ReplyDelete
  4. Niranajan there are so many… many layers…There are crimes against the indigenous communities from the beginning … From where you will start to correct the historical and contemporary injustices…If a country is in deep sleep you can put your all effort to wake them up but when they are awaken but with closed eyes they pretend that they sleeping then with what ever your noble effort…what will be the result… The challenges in front of you young people is how – without repeating the criminal and dirty path (like Rightist or Chauvinist or hate or violence politics) of so called civilized society to achieve your goal.
    I came a cross this African proverbs…
    “Until lions have their historians,
    tales of the hunt’,
    will always glorify the hunters.”…
    so use pen/brush/camera/ film….
    the sky is open...

    ReplyDelete
  5. first dont look at things all the time with scientific precision or excess of logic or just with the heart... Use the combination, and observe human nature... You will find some answers and some you will have to wait for...

    ReplyDelete
  6. hmmm... i understand your logic... but the question is.. are we capable enough to overcome those forces of human nature at times or not? Yes we are... because remarkable changes in the society have already been made in the past... and knowing those a positive change can be made... if we care to..

    ReplyDelete
  7. the points you have raised here are quite valid, including the GDP, which is sadly the benchmark of development. The education, which does not deal with the specific requirements of the people, and in this case, the tribal population, is useless to them. All it does is to make them away from their heritage and their sense of love for the forest...it is almost like dragging them from their world, to an alien world and saying now you are civilised, earn!

    And the naxalite problem is something which can be solved, if both the government and naxalities are ready to listen to each other...and are not misinterpreted...

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's not just a question of land-grabbing and greed. The tribal populations have been systematically separated from their language, their values, and their lifestyle. Over the decades, the political and cultural majority made every effort to strengthen the language of a particular group of North indians under the guise of 'national language', disregarding all other indigenous languages. In fact, the state systematically murdered the tribal languages... let's take it from there.....

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have placed a link to your blog on mine, and am looking forward to more posts here!
    http://fragbows.blogspot.com/2010/02/lonely-tunes.html

    ReplyDelete